Upgrade to Pro

Eld MLB The Show 25 Stubs: Top Players to Retain

Top Players to MLB The Show 25 Stubs Retain:

These players are either young with high potential or capable of contributing long-term:

CF Luis Robert Jr. (27 | 77 OVR | B Potential): Luis Robert Jr. is your building block. He's solid both offensively and defensively, and with some development, he can become one of the league's top players.

SP Bryse Wilson (26 | 73 OVR | B Potential): A young, controllable arm that can anchor your rotation for the next few years.

SP Drew Thorpe (23 | 72 OVR | B Potential): Ready for the big leagues and a key part of your future rotation.

SS Colson Montgomery (22 | 70+ OVR | B Potential): A high-upside shortstop prospect ready to step into the starting lineup.

C Kyle Teel (23 | 70+ OVR | B Potential): Teel is your future behind the plate. Promote him to the major leagues and get him playing time.

SP Noah Schultz (21 | 69 OVR | A Potential): Keep him in the minors for now, but he has ace potential and should be brought up in the 2026 season.

These six players are the cornerstone of your rebuild, and they should form the core of cheap MLB The Show 25 Stubs your team moving forward.